Friday, 11 November 2016

Underuse of Rare Earth Minerals

As per industry reports, the rare earth industry in India is underused and lies wasted. The Indian Rare Earth Industry is worth Rs. 90,000 crore of annual turnover.
As per estimates by Beach Minerals Producers Association, the industry can net a capital employment of about Rs 121,000 crore.
The rare earths found in India are one of the most significant ones. Collectively called Beach Sand Minerals (BSM), they include Ilmenite, Sillimanite, Garnet, Zircon, Monazite and Rutile and amount for almost 35 per cent of the world’s total beach sand mineral deposits.

"In 1998, they started freeing up the industry and in 2006, those minerals were taken off the prescribed substances list and for some reason, they have recently been put back on. So, the country has actually gone backwards. There is no justification," said Grant Smith, director-overseas operations at V. V. Minerals. "No one is getting the licences. It has been reserved specifically for PSUs through the DAE (department of atomic energy). So, at the moment, it is only the IndiaRare Earths and the Kerala operations."

"There is a perception here in India that monazite is an atomic mineral. It is actually not. Monazite is just a mineral that contains thorium and very very small amounts of uranium. But the major constituent in monazite is rare earth," said Smith. "In today’s world, China controls over 95 per cent of the rare earth market. India is not realizing any potential. You have to separate the mineral monazite from its constituents. None of the other rare earths have any thorium in them. They are associated in the ore body but not in the actual mineral."
C Swamydas, chief advisor for V V Minerals, said that proposals have been given to take on all the cost of setting up the plant, and even pay to let the atomic energy department put its own people process monazite. He added that, "We shall give the thorium (produced) to the government for free. They can store it for future use."

Though there is so much potential and scope, the industry lacks clear policies for beach and sand mining. This results in unclear rules and misleading on allegations of illegal sand mining beach mining companies.

Monday, 7 November 2016

Goa Government Lifts Mining Transportation Ban

Mining operations should be in full swing by the start of October. Prasanna Acharya, director of Mines and Geology, issued a statement informing the mining companies of the ban having been lifted.
The transportation of mineral by road was banned in the interest of public safety after some accidents on the main road came to light. On the request of locals, the government decided to ban transportation of minerals till monsoon had rescinded.
“Public safety is of utmost importance. With the lack of mining transportation roads in Goa, the trucks took to main road. A couple of accidents were reported by locals and the government was quick to take an action. Transportation was suspended till monsoon was over. The government also plans to construct a dedicated road for mining transportation,” says Vaikundarajan.



Thursday, 25 August 2016

Thorium Scam Doesn’t Exist, Says Vaikundarajan

The World Nuclear Association stated that India has seen a considerable decline in the amount of thorium deposits. The beach minerals have depleted from 300000 tonnes to 200000 tonnes across the Indian coastline. Monazite quantity has also decreased by more than 2.1 million tonnes.

Being the largest producer of Garnet and Ilmenite, VV Minerals is being scrutinised by the stake holders. However, S Vaikundarajan, founder of VV Minerals stated, “The mineral rich sand is getting washed away from the Indian coastline in the absence of mining, and as a result, Sri Lanka, located further down, is reaping rich benefits at the cost of Indian industry.”

To pull off a scam of such extent is impossible for one company alone. Due to global warming, the rising water level is causing a lot of problems across the world. With the water moving in on the shores, India may lose a lot of mineral reserves. Soon, India may also lose its Thorium rich status.
Indian Rare Earths Ltd (IREL), a public sector undertaking under the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE), is the only company exporting Monazite said V Narayanasamy, Minister of State in the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), to the Lok Sabha, on November 30, 2011. Monazite is a source of Thorium.
“Ilmenite, Rutile, Leucoxene, Garnet, Sillimanite and Zircon are separated from beach sands and these individual heavy minerals — free of Monazite — are being exported.” said the Minister.

No licence or permission is required from DAE for these substances due to the delisting of Ilmenite, Rutile, Zircon, etc. from the list of prescribed substances, said V Narayanasamy.

Friday, 19 August 2016

VV Minerals Asked To Re-submit The Draft Scheme



The Madras High Court addressed by Chief Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Justice TS Sivagnanam set aside an order quashing the rejection of mining scheme of one of the leading mining companies VV Minerals and Transworld Garnet India. The court noted that the order issued by the Single Bench was bereft of any reason and did not deal with the respective submissions of the learned counsel for the parties.

VV Minerals India had submitted a plea to cure the defects examined by the bureau in the draft mining scheme. The compliances will not have to be resubmitted and examined in accordance with the law by the authority.

Monday, 8 August 2016

Thorium Scam Made-Up To Defame VV Minerals India





The World Nuclear Association estimated 3,00,000 tonnes of Thorium deposit in India. However, in recent years India has seen a depletion of these deposits. As per the reports, around 2,00,000 tonnes of Thorium-Oxide is missing from the country. Along with Thorium, Monazite quantity has also seen a decline along the coastline by more than 2.1 million tonnes.

VV Minerals, the largest sand beach mining company, has been at the receiving end of a Thorium scam. These allegations against the company cannot be justified simply because VV Minerals is the largest producer of Garnet and Ilmenite. VV Minerals stated, “The mineral rich sand is getting washed away from the Indian coastline in the absence of mining, and as a result, Sri Lanka, located further down, is reaping rich benefits at the cost of Indian industry.”

As per some allegations, Thorium scam is reported to be worth 96,000 crore rupees. It is practically impossible for one company to pull off a scam of such extent. VV Mineral Vaikundarajan further explains that the rising water level from global warming is also responsible for these depletions. “The water is moving is on the shores resulting in India losing a lot of mineral reserves,” he explains. At this rate, India may soon lose its Thorium rich status.

Currently, Indian Rare Earths Ltd is the only company exporting Monazite. Other minerals such as Ilmenite, Rutile, Leucoxene, Garnet, Silimanite and Zircon are separated from beach sands before exporting. No licence or permission is required from DAE to export these minerals due to their delisting from the list of prescribed substances.

VV Mineral Vaikundarajan believes that these are natural problems that need to be dealt with. Allegations against the company are complete fabrication and will lead to nothing.

Friday, 29 July 2016

Mining Scam Allegations Against VV Mineral Surface Without Any Proof



VV Minerals is the largest producer and exporter of Garnet and Ilmenite minerals in India. Founded in the late 1980s by S Vaikundarajan, the company has established itself as one of the leading sand beach mining companies in the country. However, the efforts of two decades have been jeopardised by the recent allegations of illegal mining against the company.

The allegations were further aggravated when V Sundaram, the first district collector of Tirunelveli, sent a letter to the Chief Secretary of Tamil Nadu. The letter targeted VV Mineral and accused it of amassing several crore rupees through illegal sand beach mining.

The director of VV Mineral Mining, V Subramanian, dismissed all the allegations as a conspiracy theory against the company. “Sundaram is passing this as a cruel joke. He is on the payroll of our business rival... Our hands are clear. We will come out clear from these allegations. Our records are straight,” Ravindram Duraiswami, advocate for VV Mineral told NDTV.

Thursday, 7 July 2016

V Subramanian Speaks On The Growth Of Heavy Minerals Industry

V-Subramanian-Director-VV-Mineral-VVM
VV Mineral, one of the largest exporters of beach minerals in India, was founded by  VV Mineral Vaikundarajan in the late 1980s. It has won several national awards for its contribution to the export business. In an interview with Governance Today, V Subramanian speaks on India’s position in the global market and its growth.

Governance Today: What is the size of heavy minerals market in India?

V Subramanian: India has nearly 35% of world deposits but contributes only 4% of global production. The total beach sand resources in India are 942.58 million tonnes comprising of Ilmenite, Zircon, Rutile, Garnet, Sillimanite and Leucoxene.

Governance Today: How much does heavy minerals constitute in the total mining done in India?

V Subramanian: A paltry two per cent of the entire mining is done in India. Although India possesses the world’s largest reserves of heavy mineral sands at 25%-28%, its exploitation is very low at 5%- 6%.

Governance Today: What is the utility of the minerals and how are they important for Indian economy?

V Subramanian: Heavy minerals have a critical application in industries such as electronics, ceramics, pigments, paints, paper, plastics, pharmaceuticals, aerospace and defence. As you can see, they are important for our economy as they contribute to a large number of industries.

Governance Today: What are the major policy bottlenecks that are affecting industry growth despite the scope?

V Subramanian: Private sector gained entry in the market only 3 decades ago. The sector is growing and needs government’s support and backing. Some of the policy bottlenecks responsible holding us back are:

  • Mining and processing clearance is a long procedure with 18 government agencies involved
  • Ministry of Environment and Forest has 30 conditions in place for clearing mining. Some of them are impracticable
  • CRZ requirements are not in favour of beach mineral industry
  • Export licenses are to be renewed every year

Governance Today: What are the opportunities in this sector?

V Subramanian: We have an opportunity to benefit nearly 30,000 crore to the exchequer. The growth of mining industry will be a boost to India’s GDP. Private companies contribute about 5% of the world’s heavy mineral production. With the government’ support, this number can go up to 50% of the world’s production.

Governance Today: Where do you foresee this industry in next five years?

V Subramanian: The industry has a potential to grow up to 30-50 per cent in the next five years.

Governance Today: What is your annual output of heavy minerals each year in India?

V Subramanian: We export close to 7,00,000 tonnes of heavy minerals each year which is valued at Rs 850 crores approximately.

Governance Today: What is the infrastructure of VV Minerals and who are its close competitors?

V Subramanian: VV Mineral owns about 9 Mineral separation plants with each dry plant having its own pre-concentration plants, a huge fleet of trucks and earth moving equipment, 12 warehouses with a storage capacity of 600,000 tonnes, a full-fledged R&D Department, Exploration team with Drill Rig, Centralised laboratory and first of its kind Ship loader (which can load 21,000 tonnes/ day). We have few fellow mineral producers in India, namely Indian Rare Earth (Government of India), Trimex Sands, Indian Ocean Garnet Sands, and few other small companies.

Governance Today: What support do you need for developing heavy minerals mining in India?

VSubramanian: Quick clearance for the mining industry

  • Export incentives that allow India to be a competitive player in global market
  • Restrictive import policy 
  • Simplification in process for MoEF as well as CRZ clearances

Lastly, there is not a single large scale independent mine operating in free market conditions in India. Ironically, the fallout of the restrictions imposed by has resulted in benefiting China which controls 90 per cent of the industry.